Legislator: Improving State's Grading System for Schools a Priority

New system would put more focus on student growth

Legislation to change the way the State of Michigan grades the performance of schools could emerge from the House Education Committee in December.

Rep. Lisa Posthumus Lyons, R-Alto, chairs the House Education Committee. She also is the sponsor of House Bill 5112, which would create an A-F grading system for schools and would place greater emphasis on student academic growth.

"We've been working on some changes to the legislation," Rep. Lyons said. "We want a system that is transparent. I'm hoping we have something to put forward in committee within three weeks. ... The schools know that we're serious about this."

Rep. Lyons

The Mackinac Center for Public Policy released a study in October that showed that the Michigan Department of Education is using a flawed system to grade (and rank) the performance of schools. According to the study, the MDE's current system, "risks penalizing schools based not on their actual performance, but rather on the portion of low-income students they happen to enroll."

Audrey Spalding, director of education policy with the Mackinac Center, wrote the study. She testified on House Bill 5112 at a committee hearing and said it would be an improvement over the system the state has been using.

"It would be better," Spalding said. "It doubles Michigan's focus on student growth. The current system bases 25 percent of a school's score on student growth. The system outlined in House Bill 5112 would have 25 percent on overall growth and 25 percent on growth of the lowest-performing 30 percent of students."


See also:

Flawed State Rankings Mean Some Principals Are Out of a Job

Stay Engaged

Receive our weekly emails!

State Report Card Ranks Some Top Schools Near the Bottom

Related Articles:

Mackinac Center Responds to State’s School Rankings

Another Judge Upholds Teachers’ Right-to-Work Status; Faults Union’s Tactics

Trust Parents with School Grading System

Mackinac Center Publishes New Report to Simplify Complexities of Education Funding

Mackinac Center Will Represent Teacher Suing MEA For Keeping Him In Union

Mackinac Center: Michigan a National Innovator in Pension Reform

Stay Engaged

Simply enter your email below to receive our weekly email:


A “bottlenecker” is someone who uses the power of the government to limit competition in the market and artificially boost their own profits. Bottleneckers use a variety of methods to achieve their goals, including tax loopholes, regulations, occupational licensing requirements, minimum wage laws and many more. The end result when these special interest bottleneckers succeed is fewer choices and higher prices for consumers, fewer job opportunities for workers and less innovation throughout the economy.

Related Sites