The Michigan Association of School Administrators has been one of the most vocal organizations against what it calls “for profit” charter schools.

In an op-ed, MASA Executive Director William Mayes rails against “profiteers who will be allowed to take taxpayer dollars … ”

While Mayes complains about "profiteers" he has been paid on average a total compensation of $205,000 the past three years, according to records MASA submitted to the Internal Revenue Service. MASA makes a significant amount of its money due to its relationship with public schools.

MASA made $3.3 million on its “program service revenue” that involves two multi-day conferences it puts on and is attended by public school officials. Public school districts also pay to be members of MASA. For example, the Utica Community Schools District paid MASA $2,500 in 2011-12.

MASA is classified as a non-profit, which plays to the myth that only charter schools benefit financially in dealings with public education. The “profiteering” theme has been a main criticism of the education reform bills that include House Bill 5923, House Bill 6004 and Senate Bill 1358.

Stay Engaged

Receive our weekly emails!

Mayes didn’t respond to a request asking for an explanation how MASA is different from the charter school that hires a for-profit company to run its schools.

"Many people and organizations make profits off of the tax dollars we supply to schools to provide education for students and they have for many years,” said Michael Van Beek,  education policy director at the Mackinac Center for Public Policy.

Van Beek questioned why MASA is only criticizing charter schools for hiring for-profit vendors while public schools also have the same practices.

For example, on May 3, the Ann Arbor Public Schools district paid $21,000 to Apple Computer and $27,500 to Google.

"But where’s the outrage over the for-profit textbook companies, pencil manufacturers or Apple?" Van Beek said.


See also:

Public Schools: 'Profit' Bad For Others, Good For Us

Public School Officials Use Nonprofit For Political Action

Districts Use Taxpayer Resources To Oppose Education Bills

Debate On Education Bills Focuses On Choice


Related Articles:

The State of Private Schools in Michigan

Teachers Union Rails at For-Profit Charters While its Leaders Spike Own School Pensions

Group Hired To Assess Michigan Education Spending Always Recommends More

A Survey of Michigan's Private Education Sector

Detroit Mayor Says His Commission Will Be Independent While His City Discriminates

Detroit Schools Transition Chief Says: Restrict Charter Schools in City

Stay Engaged

Simply enter your email below to receive our weekly email:


Education Policy Director Ben DeGrow discusses his study and its context to Michigan's Adequacy Report in Education Spending, May 2016. To see study go to

Related Sites