Local government and state workers’ average weekly pay surpassed that of private sector workers in Michigan in 2009, according to an analysis done by the Mackinac Center for Public Policy.

From 2001 to 2009, state workers have seen their average weekly pay jump 33 percent from $796 to $1,058. Local government workers had a 29 percent increase from $647 to $837. Meanwhile, the private sector workers had a 14 percent increase from $722 to $824.

James Hohman, a fiscal policy analyst with the Mackinac Center, did the analysis using data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor and Statistics.

Stay Engaged

Receive our weekly emails!

“The private sector has been struggling this decade. That’s not news,” Hohman said. “The public sector keeps increasing. … The public sector compensation is growing beyond the private sector’s ability to pay for it.”

“You might expect wages to decrease given the state’s poor economy. But wage rates have been robust. Indeed, they’ve even increased in this past decade while the state has lost nearly a million jobs. But the growth of Michigan’s public sector employee wages has outpaced those of the private sector,” Hohman wrote in an e-mail.

Charles Owens, state director of the National Federation of Independent Businesses, said state and local government compensation grows even more than the private sector if benefits are included in the equation. Hohman’s analysis just looked at pay.

“I think one of the characteristics of a third-world country is when everyone wants to work for the government because that is where the money is,” Owens said.


See also:

Public Salary Database Puts Political Work of State Employee Under Scrutiny

Average Teacher Salaries Continue to Rise

The Salary History of a Michigan Public School Teacher

Thirty Percent of Shelby Twp. Police Salaries Exceed $90k

Thirty-One MEDC Salaries Top $100K

We Still Need to Reform Teacher Pay

Stay Engaged

Simply enter your email below to receive our weekly email:


Having a job — any job — is connected to lower poverty, better income mobility, lower crime rates, fewer children born out-of-wedlock and a host of other positive results. But today the right to earn a living is becoming more difficult. In 1950, only around 5 percent of workers needed an occupational license – today, more than 20 percent of workers in Michigan are required to have this special government permission to work. Licensing requirements typically include mandated educational degrees, hours of training, upfront fees, testing, continuing education and more. But reform may be coming. The Obama and Trump administrations have both focused on licensing rules, working to encourage states to lessen the burden. Research from scholars across the political spectrum are in agreement that these regulations stifle innovation, raise prices, reduce the number of jobs, encourage income inequality and raise incarceration rates. This event will feature three scholars talking about their research on occupational licensing and what lawmakers and citizens should consider when thinking about the issue.

Related Sites