Michigan's Pension Crisis Means Tax Hikes and Cutting Cops

Analysis of Michigan cities shows they are paying for more retirees than workers

David Walker is the former comptroller general of the United States and former head of the U.S. Government Accountability Office.

Michigan should transition all retirement and health care benefits for government employees to 401(k)-style benefits that are common in the private sector. That was the consensus of the West Michigan Policy Forum, which held its fifth conference in Grand Rapids on Monday.

“The status quo is unacceptable and unsustainable and we have a stewardship obligation to leave things better off in the future and you can’t do that unless you deal with these issues,” said David Walker, former comptroller general of the United States and former head of the U.S. Government Accountability Office.

Walker unveiled a study commissioned by the policy forum of employee retirement obligations of seven Michigan municipalities: Ann Arbor, Grand Rapids, Grand Traverse County, Kalamazoo, Lincoln Park, Port Huron and Saginaw.

The total unfunded liabilities for these seven municipalities came to $2.3 billion. All but Ann Arbor have taken steps to modify their defined benefit pension plans. Walker warned, though, that retiree health care costs are an even bigger problem, taking a larger and larger chunk of government revenue.

Stay Engaged

Receive our weekly emails!

The Michigan Constitution places a limit on how much a municipality can collect in property taxes. That means a city with an unfunded liability must take other steps. These include raising other taxes or cutting services, typically infrastructure and public safety.

Municipalities can collect income tax, and three of the seven in the study now do so. If they close their defined benefit pension system to newly hired employees, they can also finance their unfunded retirement obligations by issuing bonds. But that path creates debt to pay off debt. All of the municipalities have more retirees than active workers.

“By the time an employee retires, you should have funded all of their benefits, because they’re not going to give you any more service,” said Walker. He blames politicians, not workers or retirees, for the underfunding.

“Typically, what happens in the public sector is they hold the line on cash pay; they promise the sun, moon and stars on retirement benefits; they don’t fund them and then we have this ticking time bomb,” said Walker.

Unlike the federal government, states and cities can't cover their obligations by printing money. And if their tax burden becomes too high, he added, taxpayers can move out of state.

“The status quo is unacceptable and unsustainable,” said Walker. “We have a stewardship obligation to leave things better off in the future and you can’t do that unless you deal with these issues.”

After the presentation, a panel of public and private executives discussed possible solutions. The participants included Tom Menzel, the county administrator of Grand Traverse County; James Freed, the Port Huron city manager; Nick Ciaramitaro, legislative director for Michigan AFSCME Council 25; John Kennedy, president and CEO of Autocam Medical; and Doug Roberts, former Michigan treasurer.

All agreed reform was needed. They discussed the merits of closing pension systems to new employees, formulating retiree health care benefits with exchanges under the Affordable Care Act and eliminating pension abuses such as pension spiking.

Related Articles:

Seven Ann Arbor Retirees Getting Six-Figure Pensions

Taking the Pension Task Force to Task

Governor Granholm Called to Underfund Pensions 6 Years Before Company Bankruptcy

Why Michigan Pension Reform Matters

Unions Fight their Members’ Interests on Pensions

Fixing Michigan's Local Pension Problems

Stay Engaged

Simply enter your email below to receive our weekly email:


Detroit Prep is a top-rated and economically and racially diverse charter school in the city. It's growth means it needs to move out from a church basement and into a new location. Nearby is a former Detroit Public Schools building, sitting empty for years. But, worried about competition, the public school district refused to sell. For years, district and local government officials in Detroit had worked to block public charter schools. They pushed legislation at the Michigan Capitol to hinder them, refused to sell to them, transferred surplus buildings from the district to the city government and imposed deed restrictions on property sales to private developers. All of it was aimed to hinder or even prevent charter school choice outside the confines of the Detroit school district.

Related Sites